Is a stair climber better than treadmill running for fitness?
A stair climber appears about as effective as running for heart fitness, rather than clearly better.
The article reviews comparisons of Treadmill Running and Stair Climbing. It covers fitness gains, running performance, and calories used during exercise. One small study involved 30 men exercising at their hardest effort. The excerpt does not describe who took part in the other comparisons.
The findings have some nuance. At the same effort relative to each person's ability, stair climber users had lower heart rates. They also used less oxygen than people exercising on a treadmill. That means their hearts and lungs faced less demand during those sessions. The article suggests this could lead to smaller fitness gains.
Yet another comparison found that both activities improved heart and lung fitness. They also produced similar gains in running performance. A harder workout reading does not tell the whole story about progress.
In the study of 30 men, the stair climber burned about two fewer calories per minute. That result came from maximum effort, not a typical easy gym session. The article suggests greater upper-body use during running may explain the difference. It also stresses that lasting results depend on a consistent routine.
For BioSocial members, this offers a useful way to compare workout logs. Pace, session length, and effort can help put your numbers in context. Tracking Active Calories Burned alongside running performance may show different sides of progress. Comparing notes with others can also highlight which machine keeps people coming back.
What changes have you noticed in your pace, endurance, or workout numbers when using these two machines?

Comments
No comments yet.