Is Stair Climbing as good as running for fitness?
Stair Climbing can improve heart fitness about as well as running, though it may burn fewer calories.
The article reviews several studies of Stair Climbing, rather than one large test. They compared stair workouts with treadmill exercise and leg presses. One muscle study involved older adults. A separate calorie study involved 30 men.
The fitness results had some mixed details. At the same effort level for each person, stair-climber users had lower heart rates. Their bodies also used less oxygen than those using a treadmill. That suggests less demand on the heart and lungs. It could mean smaller fitness gains in some settings.
Yet another comparison found improved heart and lung fitness with stair workouts. Gains in running performance were similar to those from Treadmill Running. Less demand during a workout does not mean no benefit.
There were strength benefits, too. In older adults, muscle growth was similar to Strength Training using a leg press. Those changes were linked to greater strength. Whether younger people would see the same results remains unclear.
In the study of 30 men, stair-climber exercise burned about two fewer calories per minute than treadmill exercise. Both workouts were done at maximum effort. That finding does not tell us the calorie gap during an easy session.
For BioSocial members, this makes workout context worth recording. Session length, machine settings, and effort can help explain your numbers. Tracking Flights Climbed alongside those notes offers another way to follow your routine. Comparing similar sessions with community peers may be more useful than comparing calorie totals alone.
What changes in fitness or strength have you noticed since starting stair workouts?

Comments
No comments yet.